Showing posts with label technical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label technical. Show all posts

Saturday, October 27, 2012

Longines Ladies Dolce Vita - ETA 980.153 Battery & Strap change


Time for another battery/strap change!

Longines Ladies Dolce Vita
This time on the Missus's Longines Dolce Vita. The Dolce Vita is an extremely popular watch for ladies, being fairly well priced (at the retail level) and it is a very elegant and classy watch, at the same time very versatile. You can dress it up or down and comes with many different dial colours and styles. Hers is the beige dial with black roman numerals, giving it a hint of Cartier...

Yes - Dick Smith battery. The size was common enough and I couldn't be bothered buying the battery on ebay then waiting for it to be sent over from China.
The Dolce Vita has a snap-on case back, so fairly easy to open with the right tool. It is very tight (as it should be) so best to leave one side of the bracelet on the watch, as the end link gives you some leverage to pry open the case back. (Otherwise the case back sits very flush with the case, and you risk damaging the case/scratching the case/deep gouges on the edges which are all big no-nos when it's the Missus's watch. Even if it is already scratched to buggery...)

Leave one side of the bracelet on to use as leverage


Once it's popped open, all smooth sailing from here. As most other quartz watches, there really isn't much to see. Simple plastic casing ring with a Longines L178 movement, aka ETA 980.153. What I do find interesting is that Longines has also signed the movement with name and calibre. (Tag Heuer didn't do this with their quartz movement) I'm pretty indifferent about this aspect. It's a quartz movement that in general consumers don't see, so... meh... Battery size fitted here is 379, but according to the manual a 317 will also fit. However you'll find that the 379 is much, much more common...

Very basic movement with plastic casing ring. Nothing to write home about.
The movement is again very common. If you see a ladies watch with 3 hands, small seconds at 6:00, More likely than not this would be the movement. Haven't heard anything bad about it, so I'm going to assume that it's reliable enough. As a smaller movement it is not much cheaper to replace, a quick glance over the interwebs prices the movement at around about USD25-35.


Snapping the case back in place takes a bit of pressure but easily done. The Dolce Vita unfortunately has a less-common lug width (outside the norm of 14mm, 16mm, 18mm 20mm, etc) at 15mm across, meaning it can be a little more difficult to find aftermarket straps to fit. As the watch is quite small, a 1mm difference can be quite huge (unlike, say, squeezing a 24mm wide strap into a 23mm lugth width which would be ok...)

The versatility of the watch comes into play once again with straps. You can fit almost any colour strap to the watch (provided you can find them in 15mm width) Here it is with a lovely white strap to give it that summer feeling.


Yes- again, this is not taking into consideration the water resistant ability of the watch after the battery change. But it's not really a watch you'd stick in water anyway, and as it is, a bit of rain will not cause damage. 

Monday, September 17, 2012

ETA 955.112 (as fitted to TAG Heuer Link Quartz)


Battery Change on TAG Heuer Link Quartz - ETA 955.112 movement

I find that as watchnerds we tend to neglect quartz movements, even though they power the vast majority of watches out there, and there aren't really all that much information on them either. Previously I quickly posted about the ETA G01.211 as fitted to a CK watch and the response has been better than expected, confirming that people out there do want to know about quartz movements. So, here is a post on another popular and widely used ETA quartz movement, as fitted to a TAG Heuer Link watch.

The watch in question, and brand new battery ready to go
This watch is about 10 years old now, and this will only be its 2nd battery change. That's a pretty good run averaging 5 years on one battery. Although I must admit I'm not sure when the watch stopped! This particular model is powered by the ETA 955.112 quartz movement, which features an end-of-life indication. What this means is that when the battery runs low, the seconds hand will jump every 4 seconds rather than every second, thus telling you it's in need of some fresh juice.

All the tools I need to conduct the battery change...
I prefer to remove the bracelet on one side to have better access to open the case back. I've removed it from the lugs as it is a spring bar. You could also do it from the clasp, but in this case it was a friction pin and I couldn't be stuffed hammering it out...
ETA 955.112 is a very common quartz movement found in gents' watches. It is also one of the most reliable quartz movements you can get on the market today. The movement is easily replaceable, and a quick glance through the interwebs will net you one of these movements for about 25 bucks. So don't worry if your watch dies on you. Just drop a new movement in and you have a brand new watch again! (provided you've looked after the aesthetics side of things, ie, no scratches and dings and what not)

"Friction ball" used to open the case back. This way I won't leave nasty scratches/gouges on the case back in case I slip. BUT, the downside is that it doesn't have enough 'torque' to really fully tighten the case back
The ETA 955.112 is relatively svelte, so it looks small in the case, needing a fairly thick plastic casing ring
Another thing to keep in mind is that to be honest, not many watch companies will "sign" a quartz movement at this price point, especially since you don't see it anyway. So don't be alarmed if you just see a generic ETA movement inside. This is perfectly normal. There are also some smaller companies out there that fit a see-through case back to show a generic mechanical movement anyway, so it's nothing to be alarmed about. An unsigned movement does not a fake watch make. You'll probably find the opposite will ring true for some, as fake watches will try to convince you of their "authenticity" by "branding" the movement and everything else around it...

Movement is ETA stamped, but nothing else
Now, officially the correct battery for this movement is 371, but I have fitted a 395 battery, which has the same diametre, but it is a bit taller. For the movement the 395 will work and it won't damage the movement, unlike many people seem to think. 395 is also a much more commonly used battery compared to 371. Of course if the watch is very thin and there is not much spare "space" best to go with the 371. Other than that you won't find any issues.

395 battery fitted
Obviously the watch is not tested for water resistance since I don't have the tool, and the "grip ball" I used to loosen/tighten the case back doesn't really offer enough "torques" to properly tighten the case back. By right, I  should also change the glass seal and the back rubber seal to guarantee the watch will resist water again to 200m, but I know it's not going anywhere near water, so this doesn't bother me.

Other than that the watch should be good for another 4-5 years before needing the next battery change.


Tech Specs of ETA 955.112 Movement: (=955.114)


Movement Dimensions: 11 1/2 Ligne = 25.60mm
Movement Height: 2.50mm
Number of Jewels: 7
Minute Hand Fitting: 0.70mm
Hour Hand Fitting: 1.20mm
Second Hand Fitting: 0.20mm
Battery: 371/395

This movement is available with centre seconds (3H), or without (2H).
The position of the date can be at 3:00 or 6:00.
The date ring can be changed on this movement.

Different heights may be available.

Approx. US$25

[o]

Monday, July 30, 2012

CK Bold Chronograph - Battery & Strap Change - ETA G01.211 Movement


Recently I had the opportunity (and permission) to change the battery and strap for a friend's cK Bold Chronograph watch. It was a chance for me to practise my amateur hobby watchmaking...ermm.... yeah... Regardless he was happy for me to do it, so here we go.


First up, the watch. CK licenced the watchmaking side of the business to the Swatchgroup, meaning they benefit from their might and expertise. I quite like CK watches- I love their minimalistic design. Simple, modern lines and elegant style. For a fashion watch brand their design is quite timeless. Case quality is top notch (for the price), as you would expect from something stamped "Swiss Made". The straps, on the other hand... we'll get to that later...



Second, the movement. This watch is equipped with an ETA G10.211 quartz chronograph movement. This is one of the most widely used quartz chrono in the industry. If you have a quartz chronograph, with this particular subdial layout, chances are G10.211 is ticking away inside.

Now one thing about this particular movement is that they're designed to be replaced, and not serviced. (Like most things these days.) As you can see from the image below- the movement is completely sealed, with just the place for the battery showing. Even at the service centres, the movements are replaced rather than serviced. This reduces the service lead time, and makes things easier for all involved. So simple, in fact, if you have the tools, you could almost replace the movement yourself... (just keep in mind that it ain't easy taking those tiny chronograph hands off...)



Third, the strap. This is one issue I have with CK watches. Their straps are CRAP! Seems to be made of calf with a rubber backing and just glued together. They fall apart easily and once they're just a little bit worn, they start to look really shoddy. Does the gorgeous watch no favours whatsoever. My friend wanted something a bit more colourful so this is what it looks like now. Gives the watch a completely new look and a new lease of life.



So if you're after a CK, I'd strongly recommend getting one on the bracelet- as they're actually quite well done. If the style you like only comes on strap...  make sure it's something you can easily fit an aftermarket strap to. Otherwise... well... good luck...

[o]

Sunday, December 18, 2011

Tech Talk No. 6: Titanium vs. Steel


I had no idea what I was getting myself into when I thought I'd write about Titanium vs Steel (316L stainless steel). I thought it would be easy and be done with within minutes. How wrong was I!! After weeks of on-and-off research, I could not find anything simple and definitive. Instead, I've found vastly conflicting reports, anywhere from information that titanium is three times stronger than steel, to something along the lines of "nothing is tougher than steel".

What I realised is that we need to narrow down exactly what we are asking when it comes to titanium vs steel in terms of usage for watch cases and bracelets. And it is also highly dependent on your definitions of certain words.

So, I will do my best to break it down for you here. Feel free to chime in on the comments below if I get anything wrong, or if you have anything to add!

Titanium crystal bar - from Wikipedia

Pretty much all the watch companies will use grade 5 titanium, but does anyone know what grade 5 really means? No, it doesn't mean it's the best grade. All it means is the most common titanium alloy used. Pure titanium is hard to come by. So next time use see a watch company saying "grade 5 titanium" you will know what that means.

Here's a little quick breakdown of the different grades of titanium

American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) defines a number of alloy standards with a numbering scheme for easy reference :
  • Grades 1-4 are unalloyed and considered commercially pure
  • Grade 5, also known as Ti6Al4V, Ti-6Al-4V or Ti 6-4, is the most commonly used alloy
  • Grade 6-38 are various other titanium alloys, all with slightly different chemical composition – for more detailed description please google titanium alloy grades and click on the first result.

Titanium is stronger than steel in terms of strength to weight ratio. That is, for the same weight, titanium is stronger than steel. (Ti is about 45% lighter than steel).  But in terms of watches, for the same model, the Ti version is almost always a lot lighter than steel, meaning the two will have approcimately equal 'strength'. Titanium, however, it is also more brittle, and harder to work with than steel. This doesn't mean that titanium won't scratch. It may not scratch as easily as steel, but it will scratch. And due to it being a harder metal to work with, the scratches will be a lot more difficult to polish out.

There are good points about titanium - it is non-magnetic, hypoallergenic, light and has a distinctive colour - in watches at least, it tend to be darker. It is also highly resistance to corrosion and chlorine, and especially in salt water.

Further, titanium's yield strength, tensile strength, and thermal conductivity are better than those of many steel, but not all. 

So what does that mean for you and your watch?

If your skin is highly sensitive, and you don't like having something heavy around your wrist but still need to tell the time from something that's not plastic, ceramic or a phone, swim everyday, and tend not to look after your watch all that much, then a titanium watch is for you! Or then again, maybe you just like the look of it…




[o]

Monday, October 17, 2011

Tech Talk No. 5: Water Resistance Explained

How Water Resistant Is Your Watch?


This is in fact a very confusing issue to many, and a question that is often asked. Every time it is asked, a seemingly different answer is given. So, to clear all confusion and marketing speak/ hype, here is the definitive answer to the question, which you can use as a guide to work out whether or not you can swim with your watch.

There are many different terms used by various watch companies to indicate water resistance rating - 5 ATM, 5 BAR, WR50, 50m…etc etc...They all mean the same thing.

One thing that must be kept in mind is that "water resistant" does not mean "waterproof".

A watch is never waterproof, according to the US Federal Trade Commission : "The word proof connotes a measure of absolute protection that unfortunately does not exist with respect to watches, especially over prolonged periods of time."

Also, 50 metres water resistant does NOT mean your watch will resist water at a depth of 50 metres.

Pretty much ALL watch companies recommend getting watch seals checked every 12-18 months if you plan to use your dive watch for actual dives (as opposed to desk dives), as the seals are what's keeping the water out of your watch, and seals DO degrade over time and lose their effectiveness.

And remember, DON'T wear your watch in the shower. Why the heck would you do that? To time your shower in order to save money? Unless you like taking cold showers, take off your damn watch!


30m to 50m

Generally speaking, the depth rating on watches are a measure of atmospheric pressure and not actual depth of water. This means that if you see 30m or 50m, it's only really splash proof, meaning if you get splashes of water on the watch from the rain or from washing your hands, it's still ok. If you're rinsing your hands under the tap for extended period of time, take off the watch. Don't swim with the watch on. Note that there is an exception: Swatch watches are rated to 50m and they guarantee you can swim with them, probably due to the way they're constructed - i.e. a one-piece case.


50m to 100m

I still wouldn't swim with this watch on. It is likely that the watch won't have a screw-in crown. That means there is always the possibility of water getting through the most minute of spaces.


100m to 200m

If the watch is rated to 100m, and has a screw-in crown, then it is safe to swim with it. However, keep in mind that it is the pressure of water on the watch, so if you dive into the water, that will exert extra pressure/stress on the watch/ seal/ gasket. So, just to be on the safe side… However, as some of our more astute readers have picked up, there are other different types of crowns that will also be water resistance. For example the push-in crowns like on Panerais.


200m -300m

You'd probably be okay with the watch on for pretty much all water activity, unless you're a professional diver, in which case, you probably have a Rolex Submariner/ Sea Dweller or a Citzen Promaster already. One thing that doesn't come up often, but should, is that if you do plan to dive with your expensive $10,000 Swiss dive watch, make sure it comes with a double safety clasp, or something that has a fail safe in place i.e. if one fails, the watch will still stay on your wrist. So those "basic" Rolex clasps - the ones that go under and over, are probably also the safest, and withanything with a push button, single/ double folding clasp, the chance you might lose the watch is much higher.


300m +

Let's just say… the watch will still be ticking, even when you aren't…


So, here a few simple rules to live by. Keep these, and you won't find yourself with a fogged up watch, rusty movement, and an overhaul cost that's equal to getting a new watch :

1. DON'T wear your watch in the shower
2. If it DOESN'T have a screw-down crown of some sort, assume the watch is NOT water resistant. Unless of course the watch is rated to 100m and up, and/or it has some other type of water resistance protection on the crown...(push in, lever, compression key, etc)
3. Check your crown is screwed down before immersion. (or whatever protection it has is "on")
4. Don't unscrew the crown whilst in water, etc etc...
5. Have the seals checked regularly if you DO wear your watch in the ocean, in the pool etc.
6. Always rinse your watch thoroughly after it's been in the ocean/pool (chlorine, salt = enemies of seals).
7. Don't subject the watch to chemicals such as perfume (again, not good for the seals).


[o]

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Tech Talk No. 4: Ceramic Watches


Rado's been doing them since the late 80s. That's right. How can you forget those slick lookin' cuff-like black Rados?

But let's just get this whole "first-to-the-market" thing straight.

IWC was the first watch company to produce a watch with a ceramic (zirconium oxide) case watch, in 1986, in a perpetual calendar Da Vinci. All you other ceramic shadys are just imitatin'… I can quote their press release here, but you can easily find it online (perhaps not as easily as you'd find many many websites proclaiming that Chanel were first…).


The first ceramic watch - from IWC: the Da Vinci Perpetual Calendar in 1986, 
using Zirconium Oxide


I am surprised that IWC doesn't trumpet this fact more. Maybe they don't need to. Only they can answer that.

Here is a little bit of background: That first IWC ceramic model was produced in very small numbers because the material was difficult to machine. Over the years, technicians and engineers have acquired a lot of experience in the manufacture and machining of this extremely scratch-resistant, non-magnetic and acid-proof ceramic. The case blanks can now be formed more efficiently and with greater accuracy than before. They are sintered at temperatures between 1500 and 2000 degrees Celsius, followed by cooling in a complicated process to enable the material to attain all of its outstanding properties. Diamond tools are required for the intricate finishing of the blanks.

Now that's off my chest, let's talk about the use of ceramic for watch cases. What's so good about them and what's not so good? The first thing to know is that there are several types of ceramics. However, I could not, for the life of me, find out exactly what sort of compounds are used by which watch company. "High-tech ceramic" says nothing to me. So, all I have managed to find out is that IWC uses zirconium oxide. If Rado or Chanel or Hublot or anyone else want to chime in on why their version of ceramic is better, email us - thesydneytarts@gmail.com

So, to make it easy:

Ceramic watches

The Good:

* Scratch and dent resistant (note I do not use the word "proof" since that's a bit too absolute…)
* Resistance to acidity
* Hypoallergenic

The Bad:

It will shatter…so the bad isn't so bad as long as you don't drop the watch onto something hard… You shouldn't anyway, regardless of case material…


In summary - Ceramic is very HARD but it is not TOUGH.

The toughness is the material's ability to absorb energy.

Hardness describes a material's ability to resist scratches and dents. So, like a diamond, ceramic is very hard, but strike it at the right place, and it will break. Just as long as you don't drop it, it will remain looking like new after many, many years. But do keep in mind that like every other material, there are differing levels of quality, so one ceramic watch may not be as hard as another. You can get very cheap ceramic watches, and I can almost guarantee that it'll break a heck of a lot quicker, and easier than something from say, the powerhouses of IWC, Rado and Chanel.


[o]

Friday, September 23, 2011

The Double Red Sea-Dweller (DRSD)




We have previously written about the Rolex Ref. 5510. Today, we look at another iconic and highly collectable Rolex, the Double Red Sea-Dweller. The Reference 1655, known as the “DRSD” by Rolex fans, commenced production in the late 1960s. Very much a tool watch, it was the first Sea-Dweller to be able to reach a depth of 2000ft or 610m.


With a Cal.1575 movement, the DRSD were produced between1967-1977. This particular example is a Mark III dial with a 351xxxx serial, which dates it to around the first quarter of 1972 (the production date also stamped on inside the case back: I 72).

The breakdown of serial number is as follows:

Mark I Dial, 1.6-2.2 mil
Mark II Dial, 1.6-3.5 mil
Mark III Dial, 2.6-3.5 to 4.0 mil
Mark IV Dial, 3.0-5.2 mil

There are two main cases associated with the DRSD. A thin case, similar to that of the Submariner, usually appears for those with a 1.6 mil to 2.2 mil serial number, and a thicker case for the others.


Every Double Red has its individual serial number engraved inside the case back, which co-ordinates to its case serial number. The last 3 digits of the watch’s serial numbers were engraved on inside the case back for DRSDs Mk 1 up to Mk 3 (which is up to circa 1974). After that, Rolex decided to engrave the entire 7 digit serial number on Double Reds from Mark IV until the end of their production in 1977.


Mark I to Mark IV were all the standard original tritium dials used for DRSDs. Starting from Mark V, up to Mark VII, the tritium was replaced by luminova material.

Some of the points of note in the Ref. 1665, well-known to Rolex aficionados but an enigma to the rest of us, include the following:

1. The “2000ft = 610m” is in small font, the first ‘R’ in ‘SUBMARINER’
2. The first ‘R’ in the word “SUBMARINER” is under the hyphen. In the "clear" Rolex Crown dial the ‘A’ in the word “SUBMARINER” is under the hyphen.
3. In the "Smudge" Rolex dial the ‘W’ in “DWELLER” will always be touching the ‘D’, where as in the MK111 version there will be a slight space. The ‘D’ in lines up with the ‘R’ in “SUBMARINER”. In the Mark II dial, the ‘D’ “SEA-DWELLER” lines up with ‘I’ in “SUBMARINER”. Compared to the dial in version II, the print is also similar, the depth markings are spaced differently, and the coronet is also different.
4. Sixes on the depth rating are so called 'open 6' for the Mark I to Mark III dials, after which Rolex changed to 'close 6' for Mark IV to Mark VII. Additionally, the fonts for the depth rating were written in standard small font ‘ft’ and ‘m’ from Mark I to Mark IV, thereafter replaced by italic letter with long tailed ‘ft’ and ‘m’.


As you can tell, the owner of this Ref.1665 prefers to wear his on a NATO style strap rather than the original bracelet (yet another area of esoteria). This DRSD, although a very desirable Rolex, is no safe queen, but a much-loved and worn tool watch.


[AP]

Friday, September 9, 2011

Tech Talk No. 3: Platinum vs. White Gold Watches


There is a lot of talk about white gold versus platinum when it comes to wedding rings, but there seems to be minimal discussion on this topic in the watch world. So if you're wondering about the differences between white gold and platinum in watches, this is the place to be.

One common misconception people have about platinum is that it's harder than white gold. This is not the case.

Although they are both fairly soft metals, platinum is denser and heavier than white gold, but white gold is actually harder (how much harder depends on the alloy). This is because platinum is mostly used in an almost pure form (approx. 95% pure i.e. '950') compared to white gold, which is 75% gold and 25% other metal (such as silver and palladium). The density in platinum makes them harder to cast (higher temperature required - 1774 celcius vs 920 for 18k gold).

Platinum crystal (from wikipedia)

On the wrist, the same watch in different material will generally result in the platinum watch being around about 30% heavier than its gold counterpart. Weight is probably the easiest way to distinguish between platinum and white gold.

Looks wise, they look similar, but on careful examination white gold is 'warmer' whereas platinum is 'cooler, but truth be told, I can't tell the difference. More often than not, watch companies will produce a different dial for the platinum model in order to help differentiate it from white gold and steel watches. And quite often, it is produced in a limited number.

As an example - Platinum and white gold watches tend to come in different dial colour combos

Other ways to tell are the stamp on the back of the case (950 vs 750) and, of course, by scratching the case (if you can bring yourself to do it, or if you dare to do it). Scratching platinum watches merely pushes the material to the side (the material is displaced and you don't lose any precious metal content) and this can be restored, whereas with gold, you'd take a chunk out of it. Of course, you might need a fairly high-powered loupe to tell the difference...

One thing you may or may not notice is that most of the time, a platinum watch will be delivered with a white gold clasp, since it is a harder material. Platinum clasps might be more 'expensive' but due to it being a softer material, it'll wear quicker and not hold its shape in the long run, since it is a 'moving' part.

Platinum will also develop a patina after being worn for a while, which can best be described as a brushed, whiteish look. It is naturally white, and it is also hypoallergenic. White gold may cause allergic reactions to some people, but that really depends on what alloys are used. Nickel used to be mixed in with white gold, but as there are many people allergic to nickel, this is being used less and less in white gold these days.

Platinum used to be a lot more expensive than gold. That, coupled with the heaviness of the material due to its density, gives it a much higher perceived prestige value than gold. However, as the price difference is minimal nowadays (approx US$1830 per ounce of Pt vs. US$1790 per ounce for gold - correct as of end of August, 2011), platinum, perhaps, has become the better value precious metal?

Maybe, get in while it's cheap? 

Oh, and here's an unusual platinum watch we blogged about only recently.


[o]

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Tech Talk No.2 : 316L vs 904L (Grades of Stainless Steel)


This second in the 'Tech Talk' series will also be about watch materials, in this case, stainless steel.

A good majority of watch companies use 316L grade stainless steel for their cases. But, one brand in particular, insists on using 904L. So what's the difference? 

First, the dry stuff…

316L - Grade 316 is the standard molybdenum-bearing grade. The molybdenum gives Grade 316 high corrosion resistant properties and particularly high resistance to pitting (a form of extremely localised corrosion that leads to the creation of small holes in the metal) and crevice corrosion in chloride environments. Grade 316L is the low carbon version of 316. There is not much price difference between 316 and 316L.

Grade

C
Mn
Si
P
S
Cr
Mo
Ni
N
316L
Min
-
-
-
-
-
16.0
2.00
10.0
-
Max
0.03
2.0
 0.75
0.045
0.03
18.0
3.00
14.0
0.10


904L - Grade 904L is a non-stabilised low carbon high alloy austenitic stainless steel. The addition of copper to this grade gives it greatly improved resistance to strong reducing acids, particularly sulphuric acid. It is also highly resistant to chloride attack - both pitting/ crevice corrosion and stress corrosion cracking. It is also non-magnetic in all conditions. Further, it contains substantial content of the high cost ingredients nickel and molybdenum. 

Grade
C
Mn
Si
P
S
Cr
Mo
Ni
Cu
904L
min.
max.
-
0.020
-
2.00
-
1.00
-
0.045
-
0.035
19.0
23.0
4.0
5.0
23.0
28.0
1.0
2.0












Now that the dry stuff's out of the way what is the main advantage of 904L over 316L? 

It's not a higher grade of steel, merely a "different" grade. All that extra chromium and nickel simply means that it has better resistance to corrosion and pitting than 316L and that it is a more heat treatable steel to harden, to be used in dies, punches, bending and blanking equipment. So in fact, 904L is a "tool steel" much like how Rolex were first made to be "tool watches". 904L steel is only more expensive because it is not as popular in general application as 316L. 


Nickel chunk (from Wikipedia)



Chromium crystal and 1cm3 cube (from Wikipedia)

So what about everyday wear as divers' watches? Well 316L is not actually designed for continuous submersion in sea water. But that's not to say it's not any good. It is still extremely resistant to corrosion, nearly impervious to atmospheric and other mild corrosive agents,  and it is more than adequate for things like boat railing and exposure to sea water spray.

So would this mean that if you really wanted to go diving, you'd strap a Rolex to your wrist? Unless you're planning to dive into sulfuric acid or sodium hydroxide, it won't make a lick of difference. Plus, the seals, the movement, and most importantly, your body, would've dissolved long before that.



Molybdenum in crystalline fragment and 1 cm3 cube (from Wikipedia)

Also, how many people that wear a diving watch actually go diving with it? I think the amount of sea water most of these diving watches see are in publicity shots and perhaps at events. Watchnerds don't jokingly refer to their watches as "desk divers" for nothing!

The Omega Seamaster Chronograph Divers watch uses 316L steel

You must also keep in mind that the increased amounts of nickel and chromium and whatnot that reduce the susceptibility to corrosion and pitting only occur at high temperatures (for example, boiling concentrated nitric acid), which is not very likely in an ocean anyway.

So, at the end of the day, as long as you rinse your watch off with fresh water after a dive, or, if your sweat happens to be particularly acidic, rinse the watch every so often, she'll be right mate.

However, the higher content of nickel in 904L may lead to an allergic reaction on some people. Something to think about… (edit- according to @L_Horloger most of the nickel in 904 is captive, and not free. There is more nickel able to react in the 316, so is worse for allergies)

The Rolex Submariner Divers watch uses 904L steel


To finish off, here’s a little comparison of different materials used on diver's watches and their resistance to pitting :

The unit of measurement is PRE (Pitting Resistance Equivalent) - obviously the higher the number the better.

32 PRE (or higher) is considered as salt water resistant.

316L has a value of 24 PRE
904L has a value of 35 PRE


[o]

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Tech Talk No.1 : PVD vs DLC


(Obviously this is a topic regularly discussed in various fora, but I've trawled through a lot of them and summed it all up here, making it easier for you!)

Black watches are all the rage these days and they're really cool and stealthy. But have you ever wondered what that black stuff is? It could be simple black paint, to ceramic, and somewhere in between. The most common, however, is PVD...Or is it DLC?

I think that there are many of us who are either confused or aren't quite sure of the definition of PVD and/ or DLC. These terms seem to be interchangeable, and both are used to refer to watches with a black coloured coating. So, exactly which is which and how do we tell them apart?

Read on…

PVD is a general term encompassing many different type of coating, DLC is one of these types of coating.

For example, if we are talking about DLC, then DLC is the material and PVD is the process of applying it. Think of it as this: PVD is the brush, and DLC is the paint.

The process used by Penn State University


Here are some definitions:

PVD (Physical Vapor Deposition) is the method used to deposit thin layers of material (e.g. DLC) by condensation of vapor in a high temperature and vacuum environment.

DLC (Diamond-Like Carbon) and ADLC (Amorphous Diamond-Like Carbon - a specific type of DLC) are vaporised coatings. DLC is done with the bonding of high energy precursive carbon rapidly cooled down on the surface. It is very similar to the process of making synthetic diamonds, meaning  that the carbon coating has the same attributes as diamonds. They are extremely hard and very resistant to scratches, thus making the coated metal surfaces more durable. DLC is a very hard coating, but the thickness is also a factor. Generally speaking, the usual coating thickness is just 5 to 10 μm, or 0.005 to 0.010 mm.

However, there are several coatings by method of PVD that will make the watch look black; coating such as nickel and ceramic. Some manufacturers will specify whether the watch was coated with DLC or not. When only "PVD coating" is mentioned, it could mean a less durable material was used.

Here is the problem: DLC coating is done by PVD, but not all PVD is a DLC coating. Does that make sense?

And another thing. "Coating" is probably not the best term to use, but I struggle to come up with a better one. PVD method actually "bonds" the DLC at a molecular level rather than "coats". Plus, if you manage to scratch DLC, it cannot be repaired without removing a layer of surface material from the entire piece.

Chart taken from pvtechnology.it - this gives you a relative comparison of differences in hardness

I did touch lightly on ceramic coating. Yes, this can also be quite confusing/ misleading. Some watch companies use a ceramic "coated" steel case but call it a ceramic watch. Others use a solid ceramic case with say, a steel inner case. I'll dig into this topic in another post…


If you want to get even more technical, read on:

It should be noted that the application temperature of PVD coatings can exceed the annealing temperature ('annealing' is the heat treatment wherein a material is altered, causing changes in its properties such as strength and hardness) of the steel, making the steel soft.

Since austenitic steels are not heat treatable, the only way to harden the surface is through work-hardening. When a steel is hardened, its strength is increased, and it becomes more resistant to denting and gouging. Machining, brushing, bead blasting and polishing will work the surface and make it harder. If the PVD process exceeds the annealing temperature, there will be no way to re-harden the substrate surface and regain the resistance to dents and gouges. Even if the thin crust of the PVD coating is super hard, it is too thin to provide structural the support required to prevent damage due to denting and gouging.

A good PVD coating application will keep the application temperature low enough not to anneal the substrate material, but even then these temperatures get into the drawing temperatures and still can affect the hardness.

So, you can see that there is much more to PVD coatings than just the type of coating used. How it is applied, how the surface is prepared prior to the PVD process are as important with regards to resistance to damage.



*Note: this article only deals with the black coating on watches and does not take into account commercial/ industrial machinery/tooling usage.


[o]

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Rolex 5510 - Some notes



As we have mentioned in this previous post, Rolex 5510s have been in the news a little of late (and in the US$66,100 ebay 5510's case, this interest even appeared in the non-watch media).  Compared to the 5510 that went for US$98,500 only a matter of nine days later, the ebay one seems like a bargain, if you have that sort of money to play around with.

Why is the Rolex Ref. 5510 such a sought after watch, and not just amongst not just Rolex enthusiast? How do you identify a 5510?

Fortunately for us, one of the Tarts is a veritable encyclopaedia of vintage Rolex information, and so this information is courtesy of TonyC, whose knowledge of Rolex arcana is, simply put, amazing.